=
January 21, 2022
5 min read

Keeping on track

Keeping on track: KPIs and business review frameworks

Keeping Your Contracting Business on Track: Targets, KPIs and Business Reviews

Many contractors build successful businesses through hard work, technical ability and good client relationships. But as a business grows, keeping it on track becomes more complicated. There are more projects to manage, more people to coordinate, more money tied up in work in progress and more risks that can affect the bottom line.

It is easy to become so involved in delivering today's work that you lose sight of where the business is heading. Equally, it is possible to spend considerable time producing reports and monitoring figures without actually improving performance.

The answer is to establish a system of reviews that helps you understand what is happening, identify problems early, manage risk and make progress towards your objectives.

This does not need to be complicated. For a smaller contractor, a handful of well-chosen measures, supported by regular meetings and clear actions, can be more useful than an elaborate management system.

The important thing is to choose the right things to review, at the right time, and to act on what you learn.

1. Start with where you want the business to go

Before deciding what to measure, you need to know what you are trying to achieve.

Your objectives might include:

  • Increasing turnover or, more importantly, improving profitability.
  • Winning work from new clients or entering a different market.
  • Improving project delivery and reducing the cost of problems.
  • Strengthening cash flow and reducing working capital requirements.
  • Developing your management team so the business is less dependent on you.
  • Improving safety, quality and customer satisfaction.
  • Building a business that can grow, operate without your constant involvement or eventually be sold.

These objectives are connected. Winning more work may be undesirable if you cannot resource it properly or if the work offers inadequate margins. Increasing turnover without controlling overheads and working capital can leave you busier but financially worse off.

Your targets therefore need to reflect the business as a whole, rather than simply one aspect of its performance.

It is also important to recognise the stage your business has reached. A contractor trying to establish a reliable flow of work has different priorities from one struggling to deliver existing projects profitably, or one preparing for growth and succession.

Set targets for the business you are trying to build, not simply the business you have today.

2. The Balanced Scorecard: a foundation for reviewing performance

One of the best-known approaches to performance management is the Balanced Scorecard, developed by Robert Kaplan and David Norton in the early 1990s.

Its central idea is straightforward: financial results alone do not tell you everything you need to know about the health of a business. You also need to understand the factors that produce those results and influence future performance.

The traditional Balanced Scorecard considers four perspectives.

Financial performance

Are you making the profit you expected? Are overheads under control? Is cash flow adequate? Are projects achieving their planned margins, and is the business generating a satisfactory return?

Customers

Are clients satisfied with your work? Do they return with further projects? Are you developing the relationships and reputation needed to win the right sort of work?

Internal processes

Are projects being priced, planned and delivered effectively? Are variations being recovered? Are quality, safety, procurement and commercial controls working as intended?

Learning and growth

Do you have the skills, systems, people and leadership needed to achieve your objectives? Are managers developing? Is knowledge being retained and shared? Can the business handle the next stage of growth?

These perspectives are connected. Investing in staff development, for example, may improve project management, which can improve customer satisfaction, generate repeat work and ultimately strengthen profitability.

A review system that looks only at financial results may identify a problem after the damage has been done. Looking at the underlying drivers gives you a better chance of preventing it.

There are other considerations too, including the business's impact on the environment and wider community. These can be particularly important where clients assess sustainability credentials, workforce practices or social value when awarding contracts.

The Balanced Scorecard is a useful foundation for thinking about performance. It is not necessary, however, to implement a full corporate scorecard to benefit from it.

3. Choose a review system that suits your business

There are several established management frameworks, each with its own strengths.

  • Balanced Scorecard (BSC): provides a broad view of performance across financial, customer, process and learning perspectives. It helps ensure that one area of the business is not improved at the expense of another.
  • Objectives and Key Results (OKRs): focuses on a small number of objectives and measurable results, often reviewed quarterly. It can suit businesses that need to adapt quickly as priorities change.
  • OGSM (Objectives, Goals, Strategies and Measures): translates an overall ambition into a concise plan, helping a leadership team align its priorities.
  • Entrepreneurial Operating System (EOS): provides a structured approach to business management, including regular meetings, a small scorecard, quarterly priorities and accountability.

These approaches are not mutually exclusive, and none is automatically the right answer for every contractor.

A smaller business may not need a formal framework at all. It may simply need to agree a few priorities, establish meaningful measures, review them regularly and ensure that somebody is responsible for taking action.

The Balanced Scorecard can provide the underlying thinking: consider the whole business, not just the numbers. You can then select the practical tools that suit your circumstances.

For an SME contractor, the aim is not to adopt a fashionable system. It is to develop a review process that is simple enough to maintain and robust enough to make a difference.

4. What should a contractor measure?

The measures you choose should follow from your objectives, the risks you face and the stage your business has reached. The following are examples to consider, rather than a checklist that every contractor must adopt.

Lead generation and winning work

If your priority is to build a reliable pipeline, you might review:

  • The number and value of suitable opportunities identified.
  • The proportion of opportunities progressing to a tender.
  • Tender success rates, considered alongside the type and value of work won.
  • The value of secured work compared with the level needed to maintain the business.
  • The balance of work between existing and new clients.

The number of enquiries alone is not necessarily a good measure. Ten unsuitable opportunities may be less valuable than one well-matched project from a reliable client.

Likewise, a high tender success rate might indicate effective bidding, but it could also mean that you are pricing too cheaply or tendering only for work you were almost certain to win.

Staff performance and development

Your people are central to the performance of a contracting business. Depending on your priorities, you might review:

  • Whether key roles are filled and responsibilities are clear.
  • Progress against training and development plans.
  • Staff retention, absence and recruitment difficulties.
  • The performance and development of project managers and supervisors.
  • Whether individuals are taking appropriate responsibility for their work.

Avoid relying on a single measure, such as the number of training courses completed. Attendance does not necessarily demonstrate competence, and competence does not automatically translate into better performance.

Project management, safety and quality

Project reviews should establish whether work is being delivered safely, to the required quality, within the programme and in line with the commercial plan.

Possible measures include:

  • Programme progress against agreed milestones.
  • Forecast final cost and margin compared with the original budget.
  • Outstanding variations and the value of work not yet agreed or recovered.
  • Defects, rework and remedial costs.
  • Health and safety incidents, near misses and completion of required inspections.
  • Subcontractor performance and procurement progress.

Safety deserves particular care. A low incident count does not, on its own, demonstrate that a project is safe. It may reflect good controls, but it could also reflect under-reporting or a lack of visibility of near misses.

Project accounts and financial control

A project can appear successful operationally while quietly losing money. Regular commercial reviews should connect the work on site to its financial performance.

Useful measures and review points include:

  • Actual cost against budget, including labour, plant and materials.
  • Forecast final account and gross profit.
  • Cost to complete and the assumptions behind the forecast.
  • The value and status of variations and claims.
  • Applications for payment, certified amounts, cash received and overdue debt.
  • Work in progress and the timing of expected receipts and payments.

The aim is to understand not only what has happened, but what is likely to happen by the time the project finishes.

Customer satisfaction and key accounts

If repeat business is important to your strategy, review the strength of your client relationships.

You might consider repeat work, client feedback, complaints, the profitability and payment performance of key accounts, and whether relationships depend too heavily on one individual.

Turnover from a major client can look reassuring, but it may create a significant risk if the relationship deteriorates or the client changes its procurement strategy. Revenue concentration and the quality of the relationship both matter.

Overheads and business performance

Business-level reviews should bring the various activities together.

Possible measures include:

  • Turnover and gross profit against budget or forecast.
  • Overhead expenditure against plan.
  • Operating profit and the margin achieved.
  • Cash flow, available facilities and working capital requirements.
  • Debtor days and overdue balances.
  • The value and quality of the secured order book.
  • Management capacity and progress against strategic priorities.

A growing order book is not necessarily good news if the work is poorly priced, payment terms are unfavourable or the business lacks the resources to deliver it.

5. Targets, KPIs and actions: making the system work

A Key Performance Indicator (KPI) is a measure used to monitor something important to the performance of the business. It is not the same thing as an objective, and not every useful measure needs to be labelled a KPI.

Consider a contractor whose objective is to improve project profitability.

The target might be to achieve an agreed gross profit margin on suitable projects. Relevant indicators could include tender margins, forecast final margins, cost variances and unrecovered variations.

The review then needs to answer three questions:

  1. Are we on track? Compare actual performance and the latest forecast with the target.
  2. If not, why not? Investigate the underlying causes rather than simply recording a variance.
  3. What are we going to do about it? Agree an action, assign responsibility and set a date for reviewing progress.

A target without a review is merely an aspiration. A KPI without an action is just a number.

It is also important to distinguish between leading and lagging indicators. A lagging indicator tells you what has already happened, such as the final margin on a completed project. A leading indicator helps you anticipate what might happen, such as an adverse cost-to-complete forecast or a growing list of unresolved variations.

Both have a place. Lagging indicators help establish performance; leading indicators give you an opportunity to influence the result.

6. A health warning: the McNamara Fallacy

There is a danger in performance measurement that is particularly relevant to contracting businesses.

The McNamara Fallacy describes the mistake of giving excessive weight to what can be measured, while overlooking what is difficult to measure or cannot easily be quantified.

The idea is commonly expressed as a progression: start by measuring what is easy to measure; then give undue importance to those measures; eventually disregard what cannot readily be measured; and finally assume that what cannot be measured does not matter.

This is a real risk when setting KPIs.

A business might measure the number of tenders submitted rather than the quality of the opportunities pursued. It might reward project managers for achieving programme milestones without considering the quality of the work or the commercial consequences. It might measure safety by counting incidents, overlooking the quality of supervision and the willingness of people to report concerns.

The measure may be accurate, but the conclusion drawn from it can still be wrong.

There is also a risk that people concentrate on achieving the target rather than achieving the underlying objective. If a measure becomes a performance target, people may find ways to improve the figure without improving the business.

Not everything that matters can be measured, and not everything that can be measured matters equally.

Use a small number of relevant indicators, understand their limitations and combine them with informed discussion. Ask what the numbers are telling you, what they might be missing and whether the overall picture makes sense.

7. Managing risk: look ahead as well as back

Reviews should not be confined to reporting past performance. They should also consider what could prevent the business from achieving its objectives.

Risk management is particularly important in construction because projects involve uncertainty around design, ground conditions, labour availability, subcontractors, materials, programme, client decisions and payment.

At business level, risks might include dependence on a small number of clients, the loss of a key employee, insufficient working capital, weak estimating controls or an over-reliance on the owner.

A risk register provides a structured way to record significant risks, assess their likelihood and potential impact, identify controls and assign responsibility for managing them.

However, creating a register is only the beginning. Risks need to be reviewed as circumstances change, with particular attention to those that could materially affect safety, profitability, cash flow or the survival of the business.

A growing number of overdue payments, for example, could expose the business to a cash shortfall that threatens its ability to pay wages and suppliers. The review should identify the exposure, assess the options and agree action before the position becomes critical.

Risk reviews should also consider opportunities. A new market, a potential acquisition or a major contract may offer substantial benefits, but only if the business understands the associated risks and has the capability to manage them.

See the separate guide to Designing a risk register

8. Management standards, accreditation and winning work

As a contracting business develops, the way it manages quality, safety, people, the environment and information often becomes more important to its customers.

Some clients will want evidence of good management practices; others will require recognised certifications or membership of an approved supplier scheme before they will consider a tender.

This is where formal management standards and accreditation can add value. They can provide a framework for improving the business, demonstrate that processes are in place and help meet pre-qualification requirements.

But there is an important distinction between adopting good practice and paying for a certificate. Accreditation should support the business and its commercial objectives, not become an end in itself.

The ISO management standards

Four standards are particularly relevant to consider as a contractor develops its management systems.

ISO 9001 — Quality management

ISO 9001 provides a framework for managing quality, controlling processes, meeting customer requirements and improving performance. For a contractor, this can include consistent procedures, document control, handling defects and complaints, and learning from completed projects.

ISO 14001 — Environmental management

ISO 14001 concerns the management of environmental impacts. Depending on the work undertaken, this might involve waste, pollution prevention, resource use, environmental risks and compliance with relevant requirements.

ISO 45001 — Occupational health and safety

ISO 45001 provides a structured approach to managing occupational health and safety. It supports the identification of hazards, implementation of controls, staff involvement, incident investigation and continual improvement.

ISO/IEC 27001 — Information security

ISO/IEC 27001 addresses the management of information security risks. This can become increasingly relevant as a contractor handles more digital project information, client data, commercial information and interconnected systems.

Not every contractor needs all four standards. Their relevance depends on the type and scale of work, the information handled, customer expectations and the risks involved.

For many construction businesses, quality, environmental management and health and safety will be the natural starting points. Information security may become a priority where clients, contracts or the nature of the business demand it.

Certification against an ISO management-system standard is generally undertaken by an independent certification body; ISO itself does not certify companies. Where a tender requires certification, check the precise requirement, usually the certifying body must be accredited by UKAS or an equivalent recognised body. Requirements can differ between clients and procurement schemes.

Investors in People — developing your workforce

Investors in People (IiP) focuses on how organisations lead, support and develop their people.

For a contractor, this may provide a useful framework for reviewing leadership, employee engagement, management capability, training and development. These are important considerations when the business is moving beyond an owner-led structure and needs other people to take greater responsibility.

As with ISO standards, the value lies in the improvements made, not simply in holding a certificate. Consider whether the framework addresses a genuine need and whether any recognition it provides will be valued by your clients or prospective employees.

B Corp — broader business responsibility

B Corp certification has also become a prominent way for businesses to demonstrate a commitment to social and environmental performance, transparency and accountability.

Its broader perspective may be relevant to contractors whose clients value responsible procurement, sustainability, workforce practices and wider social impact.

However, B Corp is not a substitute for a construction-specific quality or safety management system. It is a different form of assessment, with its own requirements and certification process. A contractor should consider whether it fits the company's values, strategy, resources and target market before committing to it.

From internal reviews to external accreditation

These standards and schemes can help a business establish and demonstrate good practice. They can also provide useful prompts when deciding what needs to be reviewed.

For example, an ISO 9001-based system encourages attention to customer satisfaction, process performance and continual improvement. ISO 45001 encourages systematic consideration of health and safety risks. An approach to people development may lead to more consistent reviews of competence and training.

In this way, formal standards can reinforce the review process described earlier. They provide structure and external expectations, but the contractor still needs to decide what matters most, monitor performance and act on the findings.

There is no need to pursue every accreditation. Choose those that support your objectives or open doors to work you actually want to win.

9. Constructionline and pre-qualification: the next step

For contractors seeking work from larger organisations, public-sector clients or major construction companies, management systems are often only part of the picture.

Procurement teams may also require evidence of financial standing, insurance, health and safety arrangements, environmental policies, relevant experience and other aspects of business competence.

Constructionline is one route through which contractors can demonstrate information about their business to prospective customers. Depending on the level and scheme involved, additional evidence or assessments may be required. Other client-specific and industry assessment schemes may serve similar purposes.

These requirements can be important when bidding for work, but they should be approached in the right order.

If a business is still struggling to understand its project margins, control overheads or maintain reliable cash flow, a major investment in accreditations may not be its most pressing priority.

A sensible progression is:

  1. Get the business on an even keel. Establish basic financial control, understand project profitability, improve pricing and identify the most important operational risks.
  2. Set a few meaningful targets. Introduce regular reviews of the areas that need improvement, with clear responsibilities and follow-up actions.
  3. Build consistent processes. Develop the procedures, records and management controls that make good performance repeatable rather than dependent on the owner remembering everything.
  4. Identify the requirements of your target market. Look at actual tender documents and speak to prospective clients to establish which standards, certificates and assessment schemes they expect.
  5. Invest in the appropriate accreditation. Choose the requirements that are commercially worthwhile and develop the supporting management systems properly.

This is not a rigid sequence. If a particular certification is essential to secure a valuable contract, it may need to be addressed earlier. Equally, some clients will accept alternative evidence of competence.

The key is to understand the commercial reason for pursuing each accreditation and to check the current requirements before spending time and money on it.

Constructionline and other pre-qualification arrangements should be viewed as potential gateways to suitable work, not as guarantees that work will follow.

10. How often should reviews take place?

Different issues need different review cycles. Reviewing everything monthly would be unnecessarily cumbersome; reviewing everything annually would leave many problems undiscovered for too long.

In The Fish Rots from the Head, Bob Garratt explores the importance of effective governance and the need to consider different perspectives, including short- and long-term issues and internal and external viewpoints.

This is a useful way of thinking about a contractor's review arrangements. Day-to-day operational control is not a substitute for stepping back to consider the wider business, and an internal view may not reveal everything that a client, external adviser or independent reviewer would notice.

A practical arrangement might look like this:

Daily or weekly — operational control

Site teams and project managers review immediate priorities, safety, labour, programme, resources and emerging problems.

Monthly — commercial and financial performance

Review project accounts, cost forecasts, variations, cash flow, overheads and business performance. Investigate significant variances and update forecasts.

Quarterly — business priorities and risk

Consider progress against strategic targets, the order book, client relationships, management capacity, key risks and actions that require attention across the business.

Annually — direction and resilience

Review the business plan, market conditions, financial objectives, organisational structure, succession, investment requirements and longer-term risks.

At significant events — additional reviews

A major contract award, the loss of a key client, a serious safety incident, the departure of an important member of staff or a sudden cash-flow problem may justify an immediate review rather than waiting for the next scheduled meeting.

External perspectives can also be valuable. An independent adviser, accountant, client or non-executive director may challenge assumptions that have become accepted internally.

The precise frequency should reflect the risks and complexity of the business. The principle is to review important issues often enough to act before they become major problems.

11. Keep the meetings focused on decisions

A review meeting should not become a lengthy recital of figures that everyone could have read beforehand.

The information needs to be available, but the meeting should focus on exceptions, risks, decisions and actions.

A useful agenda will normally cover:

  • Progress against previous actions.
  • Performance against agreed targets and forecasts.
  • Significant variances and their causes.
  • Current and emerging risks.
  • Decisions needed and opportunities to improve performance.
  • Actions, owners and deadlines.

The agenda should reflect the purpose of the meeting. A project review needs to concentrate on delivery and commercial control; a business review needs to consider the company's overall performance, direction and resilience.

You can use these suggested agendas as starting points: Review-meetings

Adapt them to the size of the business, the nature of the projects and the information you actually need to make decisions.

Most importantly, record the actions agreed and follow them up. If the same problems appear at every meeting without being resolved, the review system is not doing its job.

12. Start small, then develop the system

It is tempting to try to measure everything at once. Resist that temptation.

For a smaller contractor, start by identifying the few issues that matter most at the current stage of the business. If the immediate problem is winning enough suitable work, focus on the pipeline and tender performance. If projects are losing money, concentrate on cost forecasting, variations and project accounts. If the owner is struggling to manage growth, review delegation, management capacity and the controls needed to support the next stage.

Choose meaningful targets, agree who is responsible for monitoring them and establish a review cycle. Once that process is working, add other measures where they will genuinely improve decision-making.

As the business develops, the system should develop with it. A contractor moving from owner-led management towards a team of project managers will need different information and controls. A business preparing for larger tenders may need formal management systems and relevant accreditations. A business preparing for acquisition, succession or sale may need a greater emphasis on management independence, financial resilience and the quality of its earnings.

The Balanced Scorecard provides a useful reminder to consider the whole business. Formal standards and accreditations can help establish consistent processes and demonstrate competence where required. The practical implementation, however, should always be proportionate to the business and its objectives.

The objective is not to have the most sophisticated dashboard, the largest collection of KPIs or the longest list of certificates. It is to know where the business is heading, understand whether it is on course, recognise the risks and take action while there is still time to make a difference.

How can you improve your business reviews?

A good review system gives you greater control over your contracting business. It helps turn your objectives into practical steps, highlights problems before they become serious and ensures that the business is developing in the direction you want.

But the right system depends on your circumstances. A contractor establishing reliable financial control needs a different starting point from one with a strong order book that wants to improve margins, develop its management team or prepare for larger contracts.

Through bespoke business advice for the UK construction sector, I help contractors identify the issues that matter most, establish appropriate targets and develop practical ways to monitor and improve performance.

You do not need to introduce everything at once. We can start with the immediate priority, build on what is already working and develop the review process as your business evolves.

If you want greater control over your business and a clearer view of what needs to improve, get in touch to discuss where to start. Peter.Searle@ba4cs.co.uk‍

‍